So, I found this quote on Papercuts:
Finished “Anna Karenina” finally. Marvelous and all-encompassing, though less marvelous and less all-encompassing (can something be less all-encompassing?) than Proust, and too long, like Mahler’s Ninth. Both Tolstoy and Mahler say little in their leisurely span that can’t be said more tersely — although terser they wouldn’t be Mahler and Tolstoy. Everything’s too long. Webern is too long. This paragraph is too long.
It’s taken from Ned Rorem‘s diary and I love it. [As someone who read Anna Karenina, I can agree that I wouldn’t have minded some shortening. Although, at the time, the length didn’t disturb me as much as the infinite number of typos I found in my version. Never will buy anything from that publisher again.]
Anyway, the article on Papercuts goes on to asking the question, if there were some books which you wished were longer [not without saying that The Dark Knight was too long and bad, something with which I really can not agree]. An interesting question, I think.
They cite Atonement, which was wonderful and I can agree that I would have loved to hear more about Robbie and Cecilia and their love story. But then again, almost all Ian McEwan novels (that I’ve read so far) are too short.
Other books I can think of are
- J. M. Coetzee‘s Boyhood [which is probably what he has done with Youth, but I haven’t read that one yet]
- Oscar Wilde‘s Fairy Tales [either by including more tales or by expanding the existing ones. Or both]
- Neil Gaiman‘s Coraline [although I know that it’s a children’s book and children’s books are supposed to be short(er)]
That’s all I can think of right now. Any books you would like to see longer (or shorter)?